diff --git a/service/modules/v1/controllers/PatientController.php b/service/modules/v1/controllers/PatientController.php
index e549683..df5e138 100644
--- a/service/modules/v1/controllers/PatientController.php
+++ b/service/modules/v1/controllers/PatientController.php
@@ -430,7 +430,9 @@ class PatientController extends BaseServiceController
                     'r.is_delete' => 0,
                     'r.is_pay' => 1,
                     'r.is_cancel' => 0,
-                ])->andWhere(['r.user_patient_id' => $subQuery])->orderBy(['created_at' => SORT_DESC])
+                ])->andWhere(['r.user_patient_id' => $subQuery])
+                    ->andWhere(['r.created_at' => $subQuery->select('max_created_at')])
+                    ->orderBy(['created_at' => SORT_DESC])
                     ->with(['patient']);
                 break;
             case 2: